Sciatica · Part 1 · London & Online
Sciatica is not one condition. It is a symptom, and the treatment that actually works depends entirely on which kind you have. Part 1: how sciatica is properly diagnosed, and how to tell the causes apart.
Sciatica is not one condition. It is a symptom, and the treatment that actually works depends entirely on which kind you have. Get the type wrong and you can spend months doing the wrong thing while the real driver sits untouched. This first part covers how sciatica is properly diagnosed and how to tell the different causes apart.
The most important part of any diagnosis is working out whether the patient is safe to treat, and that means first ruling out any red flags. Red flags are serious signs or symptoms that need urgent medical attention with as little delay as possible.
These include, but are not limited to:
The word “sciatica” gets used constantly by medical professionals. For all that, it tells you very little about what is actually causing the pain. In Greek and Latin it roughly translates to “pain in the hips,” which is really just a vague nod to the general area and to how it feels. It is a description, not a diagnosis.
The sciatic nerve is the longest and largest nerve in the body. It comes from five separate nerve roots: L4, L5, S1, S2 and S3. There are three main causes of sciatica, and each one needs to be diagnosed specifically.
These rubbery, gel-like discs act as the shock absorbers of the spine and let us bend and twist. Through abnormal or repeated loading, the inner material (the nucleus) gets squished against the outer ring (the annulus) and presses on the nearby nerves, causing “sciatica.” There are several grades, depending on how much of the inner material escapes: a protrusion (a bulge, where nothing escapes), an extrusion, and a sequestration.
Disc herniations are behind the majority of sciatica presentations, and are usually caused by lifting something with the lower spine bent and twisted.
How it tends to feelTypically worse when you bend forward, sit for a while, cough or sneeze. The pain often travels below the knee, with pins and needles or numbness in a specific patch of the leg or foot.
This is the small space between two joints of the spine (the facet joints) where the nerves travel outwards. Together with the disc, these joints carry load and guide and limit how much the spine can move. When that space narrows, the nerves get squeezed more than they should be, which can lead to “sciatica.”
There are various reasons this happens. Most cases come from degenerative change (age-related change) or injury, but plenty of other processes can narrow the space, and all of them need to be screened for before settling on this diagnosis.
How it tends to feelOften the opposite of a disc. Usually worse with standing and walking, and eased when you sit or lean forward, which is why people frequently feel better hunched over a shopping trolley.
There is a piriformis muscle on each side, at the back of the hip. Broadly, it helps stabilise the hip joint and rotates the hip outwards in different positions. The sciatic nerve usually runs underneath it as it travels down the back of the hip and leg, though there are well-known variations where the nerve runs through the muscle or over the top of it.
Piriformis syndrome has several causes, including sitting for long periods, repetitive use with poor form (a poor running gait, for example), scarring, trauma and muscle spasm. In short, the nearby sciatic nerve gets irritated by the muscle, and in theory that causes “sciatica.” Even so, there are specific things to rule out first. Bleeding in the area, for instance, can put pressure on the nerve and mimic piriformis syndrome.
How it tends to feelThe pain sits more in the buttock than down the leg, tends to flare after long spells of sitting, especially driving, and is often reproduced by sitting on something hard or on a wallet.
Anything that presses on the sciatic nerve or affects how it works could, in theory, cause “sciatica.” Cancer is one example. Some of these causes belong to an entirely different set of origins, and a few have nothing to do with the nerves at all.
A good example is leg pain and cramping caused by reduced arterial blood flow to the leg, which gets worse with activity and eases with rest. It looks like sciatica, but the cause is vascular, not neurological, and it needs a completely different approach.
That is a simplified framework for understanding what causes sciatica. How the pain itself works, and how it relates to the condition, is still being investigated. Inflammation, the compression described above, and immune responses are all thought to contribute, and that is before you factor in the nervous system, genetics, lifestyle and everything else.
On a more hopeful note, many cases of sciatica settle on their own within four to eight weeks with no treatment at all.
Because sciatica so often overlaps with the lower back and the hip, it is rarely worth looking at in isolation. If your leg pain keeps returning, it is worth understanding the six most common causes of lower back pain and why hip pain keeps coming back, since the real driver often sits there rather than in the nerve itself. For more on how persistent pain is assessed as a whole system, read about the approach used here.
Stay tuned for part two.
Before you book anything
If you are not ready for a call, there are two smaller steps. Both are useful on their own.
The whole method written down. Why standard appointments miss the systemic half of the picture, regional breakdowns for lower back, neck, shoulder and hip, which blood markers matter and how to read them together, the red flags that need a doctor, and a self assessment to take into your next appointment.
Sixty minutes by video on your full history, a systemic screen, your lifestyle and a movement assessment. Then a written plan within 48 hours setting out what I think is driving your pain, why, and what to do next. Anywhere in the world.
The £9.99 comes off the £95 if you go on to book.
Free 20-minute discovery call. Bring your history, what you have tried, and what makes it better and worse. Find out which kind of sciatica you are actually dealing with and what the right approach looks like.
Online worldwide. 5-day clinical retreats in France.
thestrengthrecoveryclinic.com